Flank · a plan for White

Van't Kruijs Opening

1/1
1.e3

The most modest first move on the board. 1.e3 claims one square, commits to nothing, and politely asks Black to reveal a plan first.

Most first moves make a claim: on the center, on a diagonal, on a file. 1.e3 makes almost none. It opens the door for the king's bishop. It keeps every pawn structure available. It waits. Depending on what Black does, White can steer toward a Colle or Stonewall setup with d4 and Bd3, a Queen's Gambit a move later with d4 and c4, or a reversed French where Black has been talked into playing e5. The move is named for Maarten van 't Kruijs, a 19th-century Dutch player. It has been the connoisseur's shrug ever since.

The catch is that modesty has a price. The pawn on e3 blocks the c1-bishop's natural diagonal. By declining to fight for the center immediately, White hands back the small head start that moving first provides. Black can simply take the space on offer with ...e5 or ...d5 and develop naturally. There is no early way to punish that. Where 1.d4 and 1.e4 pose problems, 1.e3 poses a question at most.

So who plays it? People who hate theory, people who love transpositions, and people who want the game decided in the middlegame by whoever understands their structure better. That is a perfectly honorable way to play chess. But the club statistics are blunt about what the move itself achieves. It's a fresh start with the advantage of the first move already spent.

White's plan

Pick the system after Black shows a hand. Against ...d5 setups, d4, Bd3, Nf3, and castling gives a Colle-style game with a later e4 break or a Stonewall bind with f4. Against ...e5, White is playing a French Defense with an extra tempo and can counterpunch at the big center with c4 or d4 later. Another honest path is b3 and Bb2. This solves the problem bishop before it becomes one. The unifying idea: concede the opening, know the resulting structure cold, and win the middlegame.

Black's plan

Say thank you and take the center. Both ...e5 and ...d5 are excellent. Pairing ...d5 with ...c5 grabs even more space. Then Black just develops sensibly, since there is no early pressure to respond to. A useful frame: whatever setup White chooses, Black usually gets to play the position a full tempo better off than White normally would with colors reversed. No sharpness is required. Natural moves keep the whole of Black's small but real comfort.

At club level

At club level (1600-2000 on Lichess), 1.e3 is chosen in 1.2% of all games. It's the fifth most common first move, with 27.7 million games in our database. White scores just 49% with it, below break-even and behind every mainstream alternative. Black's answers all do fine. 1...e5 (36.1% of replies) scores 50% for Black. 1...d5 (22.4%) scores 52%. 1...c5 (11.7%) scores 52%. 1...Nf6 (4.9%) leads the list at 54%. Every popular reply scores at or above half for Black. This is a distinction few first moves for White manage to give away.

Live databaseLichess 1600–2000 · blitz + rapid
Van't Kruijs Opening27.7M games · Black to move
MoveWhite / draw / BlackPlayedGamesScore
36%10.0M50%
22%6.2M52%
12%3.2M52%
8.5%2.4M50%
4.9%1.4M54%
4.2%1.2M53%
4.2%1.2M51%
2.9%803k52%
2.3%643k50%
1.1%303k51%
Famous games in this line918 master games
Carlsen, M. (2864)Ding Liren (2799)2022½–½Carlsen, M.. (2862)Giri, A.. (2764)2021½–½Carlsen, M. (2843)Karjakin, Sergey (2782)2018½–½Vachier Lagrave, Maxime (2778)Caruana, Fabiano (2835)20201–0Mamedyarov, S. (2801)Giri, A. (2782)2018½–½Aronian, L. (2729)Carlsen, M. (2832)20240–1Carlsen, M. (2840)Ganguly, S. (2668)2016½–½Duda, J. (2731)Nakamura, Hi (2768)20220–1
Heroes of this opening Vachier Lagrave, Maxime · Carlsen, M. · Nakamura, Hi
Category
Flank
First move
Other
ECO
A00
Line
1. e3
Explore all 5 Van't Kruijs Opening lines
Keep exploring
Go deeper — named lines from here
Study this opening